On Pete Wells’ “In the Belly of the Blog”

February 13, 2006 
Filed under Mailbox

Got an e-mail from the Pinoy food bloggers mailing list and it seems that some food bloggers are smarting from a Food & Wine column by someone called Pete Wells. The guy doesn’t have a lot of good things to say about food blogs. In fact, he’s downright insulting especially for what he terms as “cheese-sandwich blogs”. I don’t take offense though. I don’t have a “cheese-sandwich blog”.

Actually, I agree with the guy. While he may have made sweeping generalizations, I agree that there are far too many bad food blogs around and they outnumber the good ones. And the bad blog phenomenon isn’t even peculiar to food blogs–there are simply far too many bad blogs around period.

Food Porn Watch isn’t exactly discriminating with the blogs it aggregates. Even those that steal content from bona fide food bloggers qualify as “food blogs” and are listed there. I wish it weren’t so.

I am not going to get defensive over this. If we believe that we have excellent food blogs–and I know I do–we shouldn’t feel slighted by this guy’s words.

Bookmark this page:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Fark
  • Furl
  • Kirtsy
  • NewsVine
  • Spurl
  • StumbleUpon
  • TailRank
  • TwitThis
  • Ma.gnolia



Comments

12 Comments on "On Pete Wells’ “In the Belly of the Blog”"

  1. Connie San Gabriel on Mon, 13th Feb 2006 8:48 am 

    Hi,
    I really enjoy reading through your articles. I like food and I like cooking but my husband is not a foodie and my 6-year-old is turning out just like her Dad. Anyway, it’s not really fun when you don’t have anybody to enjoy eating and cooking with. But it’s a blessing as well because I work fulltime and travel 2 and a half hours everyday. Well, as a compensation I visit a lot of food websites whenever I can find the time. So just keep on writing.
    Connie

  2. Connie on Mon, 13th Feb 2006 9:33 am 

    Hi Connie. Oooh, that’s like saying hi to myself. :grin:

    2-1/2 hours everyday… I can sympathize. I used to drive from Antipolo to Pasay and back when I was still working. The traffic and the stress were no joke.

    So long as my family eats, the blog will get updated. :lol:

  3. L.M. on Mon, 13th Feb 2006 1:45 pm 

    Thanks for posting this. I just read Pete Wells’ article - he’s free to express his own opinion just like all bloggers out there. I think there’s no such thing as a boring foodblog. After all, blogs are supposed to be online diaries. The blogger isn’t forcing anybody to read his/her blog anyway but it’s for his/her own self expression & enjoyment. So more power esp to foodbloggers!

  4. Connie on Mon, 13th Feb 2006 3:59 pm 

    Well, not all blogs are online diaries. But I agree that style is personal and no one can please everyone.

  5. sha on Tue, 14th Feb 2006 12:19 am 

    we cant please everyone…. though I seems to draw few french foodies to mine… ewan ;-)
    and Pete Wells has rights to voice out his opinions too.
    Some just cant take his criticism.
    I was not offended but am having a belly of laugh with all the hooplas

    mine certainly not cheese blog dear… mine is simply passion for food

    am off to north burbs for another meal

  6. Beng on Tue, 14th Feb 2006 7:09 am 

    Hi Connie,

    I read Mr. Wells’s article too and I’m not a bit offended, though I know that my foodblog is one of those that he mean (hihihi). Pero keber ko sa sinasabi niya :mrgreen:.

  7. Cara on Tue, 14th Feb 2006 10:40 am 

    The way I see it, if you don’t like it, stop reading it. If you do, (like how I enjoy lurking on this one!) then keep going! It’s not rocket science. :roll:

    And I DO like this blog, btw! Great ideas for a college student who misses Mom’s Asian cooking! Thanks for all the good work!

  8. Connie on Tue, 14th Feb 2006 12:49 pm 

    Sha, you’re good with Continental dishes eh. And you’re so familiar with European markets. So the French love you. :-P And definitely no cheese blog. :)

    Beng, you can’t be a cheese blog. A blog with that gorgeous goregous tiramisu entry can never be a cheese blog.

    Peter Wells is referring to one genre of food blogs. And I have seen some of them. ANd I can’t blame Wells. I mean, elegant language is definitely not a requirement in blogging. But decent grammar and spelling naman siguro… and coherent thoughts…??? It’s one thing to write for oneself, di ba, but making a private journal public means you want others to read it too. The rules change.

    That is true, Cara. Just stop reading things you don’t like. Less headache.

  9. Beng on Tue, 14th Feb 2006 7:52 pm 

    Connie dear thank you :wink:. By the way natanggap mo ba ang email ko?

  10. Keli on Tue, 14th Feb 2006 9:30 pm 

    Contrary to what Mr. Wells has said, I care about what someone had for lunch.

    I consider all food blogs educational and entertaining- from the “cheese-sandwich blog” to the sophisticated ones.

    Though the one thing that I am concerned about is when bloggers give out way too much personal information in their food blogs.

    I think that some things are better left unpublished.

  11. Connie on Tue, 14th Feb 2006 10:57 pm 

    You’re welcome, Beng. :wink: Still have to check the houseonahill account.

    That’s a good point, Keli. I’m thinking now that the reason I find some food blogs rather blonde is because I have to sift through all the personal stuff to get to the food.

  12. Idetrorce on Sat, 15th Dec 2007 8:27 pm 

    very interesting, but I don’t agree with you
    Idetrorce




PLEASE READ BEFORE SUBMITTING A COMMENT

Except for personal use, or as legitimate RSS feeds with link back to this page, NO PART OF THIS ENTRY MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY MANNER, whether individually or as part of a collection, without the owner's PRIOR written permission. This blog is a FREE service. Help maintain it by respecting the author's copyright.

Some entries have multiple pages. Most recipes are on page 2; others, on page 3 or 4. Click on the pagination links to view them.

Some entries DO NOT contain recipes.

Sorry, I don't e-mail recipes. However, you may opt to receive a weekly summary of recent Pinoy Cook food articles and recipes by using the form on the right sidebar.

About Pinoy Cook


Readers

Subscribe to Pinoy Cook's feed Subscribe in a reader

RSS feed for Pinoy Cook




The Latest